HOW A CHART IS RATED · SUBSTANCE & VOLATILITY

How a Chart Is Rated

“A good chart” is a phrase everyone uses and few define. The classics do define it — with five criteria, none of which is “equal amounts of each phase.” This page walks through those criteria, the genuine disagreements among them, and how we turn them into two measures rather than one score.

I · THE CRITERIA

What the classics actually require of a good chart

Across the five canonical texts the criteria converge, and they are structural rather than quantitative: they ask whether the pieces of a chart support each other, not whether they are present in equal measure.

01Pattern《子平真诠》Ziping · Patterns

Whether the pattern taken from the month command is properly formed, whether it carries a taboo, and whether that taboo is answered. The classics judge this first.

02Bearing《滴天髓》Ditianui · Momentum

Whether the Day Master can actually carry the wealth and authority in the chart. If it cannot, abundance becomes burden — and whether the Day Master has a real root is the hardest test of it.

03Circulation《滴天髓》Ditianui · Momentum

Whether the energy circulates or stalls and fights. A chart holding all five phases while they clash is called muddied, not harmonious.

04Climate《穷通宝鉴》Qiongtong · Climate

Whether the chart is temperate. Winter births want fire, summer births want water; without it even a formed pattern does not breathe well.

05Continuity《三命通会》Sanming · Ancient

「Pure patterns enjoy long blessings; muddied energy may be rich and noble, but not for long.」 Peak was never judged apart from duration.

II · THE DISPUTES

Three places where the judgement genuinely splits

Balance, or momentum?

One camp reads harmony as evenness and treats a lopsided chart as impoverished. The other points to the many eminent charts that are extremely lopsided, and to the maxim that what is supremely strong must not be opposed but followed. The reconciliation the texts themselves offer is that the operative quality is purity, not evenness: a chart concentrated in one direction can be superior if it is clean and its energy has somewhere to go — and inferior if it is merely arid.

Is wealth and rank the same as a good life?

The texts refuse the equation. San Ming Tong Hui states it flatly: muddied energy and a withered spirit may be rich and noble, but not for long. Di Tian Sui sets the standard as beginning where it begins and ending where it ends. Height of achievement and durability of fortune are treated as two findings, and a chart can score high on one while failing the other.

How much belongs to the chart, and how much to timing?

Ziping Zhenquan draws the line itself: a high pattern the cycles never assist goes unmet for life, while a low pattern the cycles do assist can reach modest comfort. Shen Feng Tong Kao sharpens it into the doctrine of ailment and cure — a chart with an ailment can be noble, but only if there is a cure. Where that cure sits is decisive: inside the chart it is self-sufficiency; only in the cycles it is dependency.

III · THE METHOD

Two measures, derived from the third dispute

Only the natal chart is knowable in advance; the cycles are not our subject here. So we score the chart on what it can claim without help — and, separately, on how much help it needs. The two questions do not substitute for each other, so they get two numbers.

SUBSTANCESubstance

What the chart is worth on its own terms — the expected thickness of fortune before any cycle is consulted.

  • Pattern:formed / spoiled / spoiled-then-answered, weighted by how close and how potent the acting element is
  • Bearing:temperance of strength, and whether the Day Master owns a real root in the branches
  • Circulation:continuity of the generating chain; clash configurations deduct
  • Climate:fire for winter births, water for summer births
  • Purity:whether the pivot element is visible in the stems or buried in the branches
VOLATILITYVolatility

How far this chart travels when the cycles turn — amplitude, with no direction implied.

  • Borrowed footing:charts that surrender to a dominant force rise and fall with it
  • Cure deferred:a serious ailment whose remedy is absent from the chart must wait on timing
  • Rootlessness:without a root of its own, advance and retreat are decided by others
  • Kinetics:the four horses, the four vaults, stem-and-branch double clashes, punishments
  • Extremity:a chart concentrated into a single phase has no dissipation path

Both are reported as percentiles, against the complete enumeration of 518,400 possible charts — every combination of year, month, day and hour pillar. A percentile is the honest unit here: it says where you sit among all possible configurations, and it does not pretend that “84” means anything absolute.

IV · HOW TO READ IT

Nine readings from two axes

Neither axis alone is a verdict. Read the pair: the same Substance means very different things at the two ends of the volatility range.

Low volatility
Mid volatility
High volatility
High substance
Bedrock

A clean, self-standing structure with few violent turns — the classical ideal of a life that finishes what it began.

Timber

Deep footing and an eventful road: it stands first, then climbs through change.

Maverick

Both structure and amplitude run high. A very large ceiling, paid for in calm years.

Mid substance
Even Keel

No grand pattern, no grave damage. Smoothness is its strength, not its absence of one.

Common Road

Mid-population. Gains and losses both ordinary; the road is decided more by choice than by configuration.

Wave Rider

Median substance, wide amplitude — opportunity and exposure amplified together.

Low substance
Quiet Keep

Plain configuration, quiet waters. The classics counted peace as its own category — this is that category.

Whetstone

The chart has a gap and the remedy is not inside it — time and effort must supply what the configuration did not.

All-In

Wide gaps and wide swings, outcomes tightly coupled to timing: fast to rise, hard to hold.

V · QUESTIONS

Questions this rating raises

Does a low Substance score mean a bad life?

No. Substance measures how self-sufficient the starting configuration is — whether the pattern forms, whether the Day Master can carry it, whether the energy circulates. It describes the shape of the start, not the height of the finish. The classics counted peace, wealth, and rank as separate goods for exactly this reason.

Why not merge the two measures into one ranking score?

Because they answer different questions, and averaging them destroys the useful part. A clean pattern with small swings and a clean pattern with violent swings would collapse to the same number — yet the classical advice for the two is opposite: one should consolidate, the other should pick its moment.

Is high Volatility good or bad?

It has magnitude, not direction. High volatility means both the upside and the downside widen. When the classics discuss charts that borrow their footing from a dominant force, they always state both halves: soaring when the cycles favour it, collapsing when they turn.

My chart holds all five phases — why is Substance not high?

Holding all five phases and being harmonious are different things. The canonical gloss defines harmony as five conditions: a formed pattern, temperate momentum, a Day Master that is not weak, a potent pivot element, and no clash or breakage. A chart holding all five while they war satisfies none of them.

Is rarity the same thing as Substance?

Rarity is simply the Substance percentile, banded — the two are monotonically linked. Volatility deliberately does not enter rarity: if amplitude counted, the most lopsided charts would occupy the top tier, which is the opposite of what the classics judge.

Will the same chart's score change later?

Under a given algorithm version the same chart always yields the same score — the rating is a deterministic function with no random component. The algorithm itself is revised as research progresses; every card and report records the version that produced it.

Can this rating predict specific events?

It cannot, and does not try to. It reads the structural features of one fixed configuration — the composition of a hand, not the outcome of the game. Timing belongs to the luck cycles, and choice belongs to the person.

Want to see your own two measures? Cast the chart → or← Compendium